Home » Business, Leadership

Honesty Doesn’t Seem To Be The Best Policy

20 May 2010 0 views View Comments

Welcome back... feel free to look around and see what's new!

recognition Honesty Doesnt Seem To Be The Best PolicyBased on experience, both working in the trenches and from the outside as a consultant, I have found that honesty doesn’t seem to be the best policy in corporate America. When it comes to “evaluating” (or recognizing as I like to refer to it as) people fairly about their work, most companies fail miserably. Jack Welch, former CEO of General Electric Company and author of the book Winning, says that companies who don’t give honest and descriptive feedback cannot expect to be very effective at managing them. Instead, leaders need to make sure the proper steps are in place to the people within the organization receive relevant feedback.

Feedback needs to be based on criteria that both management and employees agree on. These types of evaluations can come in many different forms. I’ve found that most companies base wage compensation increases on performance evaluations that occur annually and sometimes, semi-annually. But more frequent and informal feedback can make all the difference in the world. Welch writes, “I’ve evaluated twenty or so direct reports with frequent handwritten notes that included two pieces of information: what I thought the person did well, and how I thought they could improve.”

According to Welch, even organizations that have good evaluation systems are usually missing the most important element…integrity. Since most organizations focus solely on the bottom line, managers most often overlook personal conduct when result is big profit. To close, merit-based awards and proper recognition, Welch says, should be a standard. After all, everybody likes to know that their commitment and efforts are appreciated.

I’d like this to be an open discussion using the comment box below… how are you maintaining a transparent work environment?

If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!
  • http://twitter.com/geoff_snyder/status/14366790501 Geoff Snyder

    Honesty Doesn’t Seem To Be The Best Policy: "I've evaluated twenty or so direct reports with frequent handwritten … http://bit.ly/ayBq35

  • http://twitter.com/geoff_snyder/status/14378326767 Geoff Snyder

    Honesty Doesn’t Seem To Be The Best Policy http://bit.ly/9r33Ei #recognition #integrity

  • http://topsy.com/trackback?utm_source=pingback&utm_campaign=L2&url=http://www.geoffsnyder.com/honesty-doesnt-seem-to-be-the-best-policy/ Tweets that mention Honesty Doesn’t Seem To Be The Best Policy | Freedom to Think and Dream Big — Topsy.com

    [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Geoff Snyder, Geoff Snyder. Geoff Snyder said: Honesty Doesn’t Seem To Be The Best Policy: "I've evaluated twenty or so direct reports with frequent handwritten … http://bit.ly/ayBq35 [...]

  • http://twitter.com/rdeclermont/status/14388467611 Renaud de Clermont

    Honesty Doesn't Seem To Be The Best Policy: http://bit.ly/9PDY01 via @addthis

  • Geoff Snyder

    Honesty Doesn’t Seem To Be The Best Policy http://bit.ly/9r33Ei #recognition #integrity

  • http://www.geoffsnyder.com/criticism-and-praise/ Criticism and Praise | Freedom to Think and Dream Big

    [...] you're new here, you may want to subscribe to my RSS feed. Thanks for visiting! After posting Honesty Doesn’t Seem To Be The Best Policy last week, I received several emails asking for a follow up post. So, I guess I’ll label this [...]

  • http://twitter.com/geoff_snyder/status/16458351665 Geoff Snyder

    Honesty Doesn't Seem To Be The Best Policy http://bit.ly/cCJDyV

  • http://twitter.com/expertinservice James Sorensen

    Nice post. As mentioned frequent evaluations other than the standard yearly or semi-annual review are necessary to gauge employee performance. Frequent reviews or individual meetings give employee’s ample time for improvement if required and helps keep employees on track to achieve goals. Unless employees and employers keep detailed records, it’s often difficult to remember what has occurred in terms of employee performance at 6 months or a years time. Consistently documenting employee achievements during the year helps greatly and provides a more well rounded performance review.

  • Anonymous

    Thank you James. You’re absolutely right about keeping track of employee achievements. I think it’s also an good way to engage with your team, as for it’s a great opportunity to listen to what is going on outside of each other’s daily efforts.

  • http://twitter.com/expertinservice/status/22387867412 James Sorensen

    Nice post. RT @Geoff_Snyder: Honesty Doesn't Seem To Be The Best Policy http://bit.ly/cCJDyV

  • http://twitter.com/geoff_snyder/status/22389915920 Geoff Snyder

    @expertinservice: Thank you for your input on honesty within the workplace. I also appreciate the RT http://bit.ly/cCJDyV

blog comments powered by Disqus